Garry Cleaver:

Pretty good but the chair rotation is overpowering the scene for me.

Sanamani Singh:

good layout but the chair movement is bit too much and distracting ..there are some good expression but animation still need lots of polishing

John Fraire:

Chair could have another texture just to differenciate from the walls; that was confusing in the first shot

Ezra Allen:

Nice I like it. Needs more eye contact. You have a head nod on secret and must that I think is too harsh and I think blinking on both? lose the blinks and you will have more intensity. The chair swing is nice but in the first shot it's a bit distracting because you can't tell it's a chair. f183 the point hits too hard. Nice work best I seen so far.